Why Across-the-Board Price Increases Often Miss the Mark

A recent podcast conversation about pricing analytics, customer behavior, seasonality, AI, and the decisions that ultimately drive profitability.

I recently joined Gwinnett Business Radio International for a wide-ranging conversation about pricing and how to make correct pricing decisions.

Pricing is often treated as a simple and episodic administrative exercise. Costs rise, leadership chooses a target number, and every price goes up by roughly the same amount. The process is easy to explain and relatively easy to implement.

Unfortunately, this approach usually leaves a considerable amount of profit on the table, and puts valuable sales volume at risk.

In the podcast, I explained why effective pricing is less about choosing one number and more about making a series of targeted, granular and, ideally, data-driven, decisions.

[Listen to the conversation on Apple Podcasts.]

The problem with “across the board” price increases

Suppose a company wants a price increase to average 3%; that’s typical in most companies that operate under target budgets, which is the vast majority of businesses. The most straightforward solution is to raise the price of every product included in the increase by 3%.

The problem with this approach is that products do not all behave in the same way. Some products are highly “visible”, and therefore quite sensitive to price changes; even a small increase will affect purchasing behavior and encourage customers to check competitors. On the other hand, some products (in fact, the majority of them in a given portfolio) are not sensitive at all to price changes and can sustain higher price increases without putting any volume at risk.

In practice, it means that the right way to achieve a 3% average increase might be to take no increase on some products, 10% or more on others, and a range of different actions in between. The “surface” end result is the same: the company got its 3%. However, the targeted approach leads to dramatically better outcomes in terms of volume, revenue and profitability.

[Listen to the conversation on iHeart Radio.]

What transaction data can tell us

A good starting point for a business wanting to get granular with its pricing is to look at its own data. For most companies, that means analyzing several years of transaction history: orders, quantities, prices, discounts, promotions, customer characteristics, and the timing of previous changes. The objective is to understand how customers responded and use that evidence to improve the next decision.

Did volume decline following an increase? Was the decline actually caused by price, or did seasonality and changes in the product mix play a role? Did a promotion generate incremental demand, or merely discount purchases that would have happened anyway? Which customers changed their behavior, and which did not?

Large B2B companies can have millions of such transaction records. Restaurants, retailers, and direct-to-consumer businesses may have far more. Specialized analytical tools are therefore essential.

AI can make this work more efficient by helping analysts manage multiple processes and accelerate established workflows. But it does not remove the need for commercial judgment. Data can clarify the risks and likely outcomes of a decision; it does not eliminate the responsibility to make that decision thoughtfully.

[Listen to the conversation on Spotify.]

Pricing is also about value

Cost matters, but pricing cannot be based on cost alone. A company also needs to understand its customers’ willingness to pay and the value those customers receive. Two customers buying the same product, even if it is commoditized, may still end up getting two different prices based on their purchasing behavior and strategic interest to the seller.

For example, one might place a small number of large, predictable orders, placed ahead of time. Another might make frequent, urgent, small purchases that are more expensive to process and fulfill. Even when the physical product is identical, the value and cost-to-serve equations are not.

This is where customer segmentation becomes particularly useful. It helps companies recognize meaningful differences among customers and create pricing structures that reflect those differences.

The same principle applies to service, payment terms, guarantees, delivery requirements, and other elements of the offer. Price and value are two sides of the same coin.

[Listen to the conversation on Gwinnett Business Radio.]

Timing matters more than many companies realize

A well-designed increase can still underperform if it is introduced at the wrong time. For consumer-facing businesses in particular, the goal is often to make the price change as “invisible” as possible. That can mean adjusting prices during a product’s low season so that the new pricing is already established when demand returns.

Consider a restaurant selling hot coffee. Customers tend to notice changes in coffee prices quickly, but fewer people buy hot coffee during the summer. Introducing an increase in the warmer months may attract less attention while preparing the business for peak winter demand. The opposite logic can apply to cold beverages of course.

This does not mean every increase should be hidden. It means sales seasonality should be treated as useful information rather than background noise.

Pricing decisions compound

One of the most important points from our conversation was that good pricing compounds, something that far too many companies seem to ignore entirely.

Pricing should not be viewed as a one-time intervention intended to repair every weakness in a business. It cannot compensate indefinitely for an unclear value proposition, poor service, or fundamental operational problems.

What it can do is improve profitability through a disciplined cycle of decisions: analyze, act, measure the outcome, learn, and adjust. Each well-executed decision creates a stronger foundation for the next one. Over time, the business improves not only its price levels but also its processes, governance, data, and understanding of customer behavior.

The reverse is also true. Repeated across-the-board changes, made without measuring their effects, can compound avoidable mistakes. The stop-and-go approach to pricing, in place in many businesses, is far more costly than they realize.

A difficult environment calls for greater selectivity

As we are getting into planning season for 2027, how can one improve its pricing decisions? That was the concluding segment of our conversation.

Businesses today face a challenging combination: continuing cost pressure and inflation, uncertainty around tariffs, and limited economic growth. Doing nothing may not be sustainable if costs continue to rise. But aggressive increases can be difficult to defend when customer demand is weak.

That tension makes targeted pricing even more valuable. In addition to asking, “How much should we raise prices?”, leadership teams should also ask:

  • Which prices should change?
  • For which customers?
  • By how much?
  • At what time?
  • What response should we expect?
  • How will we determine afterward whether the decision worked?

Those questions require more effort than applying a single percentage. They also produce decisions that are far more likely to protect both margin and customer relationships.

Pricing is ultimately a decision discipline. The goal is not to find one perfect number. It is to make a better decision with the available data, measure the result honestly, and use what you learn to improve the next decision.

If your organization is considering an important price or promotion decision, I would be interested to hear what is making that decision difficult.